[Blog](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/) · [Destinations](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/category/destinations/) · November 18, 2026 · 5 min read

# St. John or the British Virgin Islands: Which Sees Less Seaweed?

Neither is lighter all year. St. John and the British Virgin Islands were both at High risk on all 31 days of July and August 2025 and calmest in December and January. The gaps show up in September, October and March.

Neither is lighter all year. In the daily record from July 1, 2025 to November 16, 2026, St. John and the British Virgin Islands (BVI) were both at High risk on all 31 days of July and August 2025, and both were calmest in December and January. The differences sit in September, October and March, and they depend on which BVI island you pick.

## What does the St. John record show?

St. John's seven beaches share a single table: Honeymoon Beach, Hawksnest, Trunk Bay, Cinnamon Bay, Maho Bay, Francis Bay and Salt Pond Bay. The other six matched Honeymoon Beach on at least 93% of days, so one set of counts covers the island's coast. Each count is a day at a risk level for a run of coast, not a count of seaweed on the sand.

For Honeymoon Beach's coast, the record reads like this:

- **July and August 2025:** High on all 31 days, in both months.
- **September 2025:** High on 18 days and Medium on 12.
- **October 2025:** Low on 2 days, Warning on 7, Medium on 17 and High on 5.
- **December 2025 and January 2026:** Low on 30 of 31 days and 29 of 31.
- **April to June 2026:** High on 25, 27 and 30 days.

For the wider U.S. side, the [U.S. Virgin Islands seaweed](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/us-virgin-islands-sargassum-st-thomas-st-john-st-croix/) article covers St. Thomas and St. Croix too.

## What does the British Virgin Islands record show?

The BVI needs four tables, because its 14 beaches did not share a level on 9 days in 10. The groups are Cane Garden Bay with nine other beaches (including The Baths and Spring Bay), Savannah Bay on Virgin Gorda, White Bay on Jost Van Dyke, and Loblolly Bay on Anegada with Cow Wreck Beach.

The four tables agree on the big picture. All four were High on all 31 days in July and August 2025, and all four were High on 26 to 31 days a month from April to June 2026. They split in the shoulder months. That's where the choice of island starts to matter. For a tour of each island, see [British Virgin Islands seaweed island by island](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/british-virgin-islands-seaweed-tortola-virgin-gorda-anegada/).

## Which had more Low days, month by month?

Low-risk days matter most if you want a calm week. Here they are for the months where the two places pulled apart, with St. John alongside each BVI table.

| Month | St. John | Cane Garden Bay group | Savannah Bay | White Bay | Loblolly Bay |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 2025 | 2 | 9 | 9 | 2 | 7 |
| Nov 2025 | 17 | 19 | 22 | 19 | 21 |
| Dec 2025 | 30 | 30 | 29 | 27 | 30 |
| Jan 2026 | 29 | 28 | 29 | 29 | 29 |
| Feb 2026 | 18 | 18 | 17 | 18 | 11 |
| Mar 2026 | 6 | 5 | 0 | 4 | 0 |
| Oct 2026 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 |
| Nov 2026 (16 days) | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 8 |

From December through February the numbers sit close together, apart from Anegada's lower February count, so the island you choose would change your odds little. Outside those months the picture shifts.

## Where do the two differ?

- **September 2025.** St. John was High on 18 days and Medium on 12. The Cane Garden Bay group was High on 26, Savannah Bay and Loblolly Bay on 30 of 30 days, and White Bay on 16. In that month St. John and White Bay looked lighter than Virgin Gorda and Anegada.
- **October 2025.** St. John and White Bay had 2 Low days each, while the Cane Garden Bay group and Savannah Bay had 9 and Loblolly Bay had 7. The BVI's calmer groups started their quiet season earlier.
- **March 2026.** Savannah Bay and Loblolly Bay had no Low days at all, and were High on 7 and 8 days. St. John had 6 Low days and 1 High day.
- **November 2026, so far.** Anegada had 8 Low days in the first 16 days, against 2 for St. John and for the other three BVI tables.

The answer flips with the month and the island. For a similar island-versus-island read, see [St. Thomas or St. Croix](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/st-thomas-or-st-croix-seaweed-which-is-quieter/).

## How should you read this comparison?

NOAA's Sargassum Inundation Risk product looks at satellite floating-algae data in the 50 to 100 km around each coastal pixel and compares it with a multiday baseline. NOAA calls it experimental and says it is not a forecast. Because the neighbourhood is so wide, islands only a few miles apart often receive the same level on most days, which is why St. John and the BVI look alike for most of the year.

The level describes seaweed offshore that could arrive, not what is on the sand. It is a record of past days. If you want to read the columns for yourself, [how to read a by-month page](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/how-to-read-by-month-seaweed-page-days-at-each-level/) walks through them, and each beach page states which way the beach faces.

## What should you plan around?

In this record, December and January were the calmest months in both places, July and August were High on every day in both, and the spring months were High on most days. Between those, check the row for your dates on the [St. John by-month page](https://seaweedradar.com/st-john/by-month/) and the [BVI by-month page](https://seaweedradar.com/british-virgin-islands/by-month/). One year of data shows each month only once, so treat a gap of a few days as a hint, not a rule.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Which has less seaweed, St. John or the British Virgin Islands?

In the record from July 2025 to November 16, 2026, neither is lower all year. Both were at High risk on every day of July and August 2025 and were calmest in December and January. The gaps are in September, October and March, and they differ by BVI island.

### When was the calmest time in the Virgin Islands?

December 2025 and January 2026. St. John had Low risk on 30 of 31 days in December and 29 of 31 in January. The four BVI tables had Low on 27 to 30 days in December and 28 to 29 in January.

### Is the risk level a forecast?

No. NOAA calls its Sargassum Inundation Risk product experimental and not a forecast. The pages count past days at each level for a run of coast, not seaweed on a particular beach.

### Why does the BVI have four tables and St. John only one?

Beaches share a table only when they had the same level on at least 9 days in 10. St. John's seven beaches did. The BVI's 14 beaches split into four groups.

## Questions

**Which has less seaweed, St. John or the British Virgin Islands?**

In the record from July 2025 to November 16, 2026, neither is lower all year. Both were at High risk on every day of July and August 2025 and were calmest in December and January. The gaps are in September, October and March, and they differ by BVI island.

**When was the calmest time in the Virgin Islands?**

December 2025 and January 2026. St. John had Low risk on 30 of 31 days in December and 29 of 31 in January. The four BVI tables had Low on 27 to 30 days in December and 28 to 29 in January.

**Is the risk level a forecast?**

No. NOAA calls its Sargassum Inundation Risk product experimental and not a forecast. The pages count past days at each level for a run of coast, not seaweed on a particular beach.

**Why does the BVI have four tables and St. John only one?**

Beaches share a table only when they had the same level on at least 9 days in 10. St. John's seven beaches did. The BVI's 14 beaches split into four groups.

## Sources

- [Seaweed Radar: St. John seaweed by month](https://seaweedradar.com/st-john/by-month/)
- [Seaweed Radar: British Virgin Islands seaweed by month](https://seaweedradar.com/british-virgin-islands/by-month/)
- [NOAA/AOML: Sargassum Inundation Report (SIR)](https://cwcgom.aoml.noaa.gov/SIR/)

Tags: [st-john](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/st-john/), [british-virgin-islands](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/british-virgin-islands/), virgin-islands, [seaweed-by-month](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/seaweed-by-month/), [island-comparison](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/island-comparison/)

See the newest risk level for [399 beaches](https://seaweedradar.com/), or read [how the levels work](https://seaweedradar.com/how-it-works/).

## Morning report

The seaweed risk for your beach, by email at 7 AM local time, in English or Spanish. Each report gives the newest risk level for the coast around the beach: not a view of the sand, not a forecast.

- Every morning
- Once a week
- One weekend

[Choose a plan](https://seaweedradar.com/report/)

Trip Brief PDF with every plan. Payment on Gumroad.
