[Blog](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/) · [Destinations](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/category/destinations/) · November 18, 2026 · 4 min read

# St. Thomas or St. Croix: Which Sees Less Seaweed?

St. Thomas had more quiet days than St. Croix from November to February: Magens Bay was at the Low level on 101 of 120 days, against 66 to 88 on St. Croix's beaches. From April to August both islands ran High on most days.

Every number below comes from the daily record on Seaweed Radar, from July 1, 2025 to November 16, 2026. A level describes seaweed offshore that could arrive, so it speaks to the odds along a stretch of coast, not to the sand on a given morning.

## Which island has more quiet days?

St. Thomas, from November to February. The table counts the days each beach sat at the Low level, the quietest of the four levels. One St. Thomas beach stands for all eight on the island, because each shares its level on at least 93% of days.

| Month (days) | Magens Bay, St. Thomas | Cane Bay, St. Croix | Cramer Park Beach, St. Croix | Rainbow Beach, St. Croix |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 2025 (30) | 22 | 18 | 18 | 17 |
| Dec 2025 (31) | 27 | 9 | 17 | 5 |
| Jan 2026 (31) | 29 | 27 | 29 | 27 |
| Feb 2026 (28) | 23 | 18 | 24 | 17 |
| Total (120) | 101 | 72 | 88 | 66 |

December is where the islands part ways, and the gap is wide. Magens Bay was Low on 27 of 31 days, while Cane Bay was Low on 9 and Rainbow Beach on 5, with most other days at Medium. January is the quiet month on both islands, with 27 to 29 Low days everywhere in the table.

The full month-by-month counts are on [St. Thomas by month](https://seaweedradar.com/st-thomas/by-month/) and [St. Croix by month](https://seaweedradar.com/st-croix/by-month/). St. Croix's beaches sit in three separate groups, so its page has three tables.

## What happens in spring and summer?

Both islands run High on most days from April to August, and nothing in the record favors either one. The table shows High days for the two beaches that lead their islands' tables.

| Month 2026 | Magens Bay, St. Thomas | Cane Bay, St. Croix |
|---|---|---|
| Apr | 20 of 30 | 28 of 30 |
| May | 28 of 31 | 31 of 31 |
| Jun | 30 of 30 | 30 of 30 |
| Jul | 30 of 30 mapped days | 25 of 30 mapped days |
| Aug | 30 of 30 mapped days | 29 of 30 mapped days |

July and August 2025 were High on every day at both islands, so the summer pattern held across two years of record. In July and August 2026 one day in each month had no map, which is why those rows count mapped days.

The autumn drop comes at a different pace. In October 2026 Magens Bay was Medium on 26 days and High on 3, while Cane Bay was High on 12 and Medium on 12. If you travel in October, the record so far puts St. Thomas ahead.

## What about March and the autumn months?

March is the first month the two islands look alike again, and neither is quiet. Magens Bay was Low on 11 days, Warning on 6 and Medium on 14, with no High days. Cane Bay was Low on only 4 days, Warning on 8, Medium on 12 and High on 7, so St. Thomas still had the better March.

September 2026 was close to a tie. Magens Bay was High on 21 days and Medium on 8, and Cane Bay was High on 26 and Medium on 3. In September 2025 the picture was similar: Magens Bay was Medium on 16 days and High on 14, while Cane Bay was High on 26.

Put together, the islands are far apart only in winter and close the rest of the year. If your dates fall in December or January, the choice of island changes your odds. Between April and September, it barely does.

## Does the side of the island matter?

Much less than the island or the month. On St. Thomas the four open beaches had a higher top level than the four sheltered ones on 14 of 501 days, a lower one on 8 and the same on 479. On St. Croix the open beaches were higher on 8 days, lower on none and the same on 493.

Open beaches are usually the first to collect seaweed when it arrives, and sheltered ones often collect less, though not every time. A higher level on one side means more risk offshore there, not more seaweed on its sand. The [St. Thomas open and sheltered beaches](https://seaweedradar.com/st-thomas/which-side/) and [St. Croix open and sheltered beaches](https://seaweedradar.com/st-croix/which-side/) pages show the day counts, and [do sheltered beaches get less seaweed](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/do-sheltered-beaches-get-less-seaweed/) covers the question across destinations.

## What do the levels not tell you?

They are a satellite-based risk for a run of coast. NOAA calls the daily product experimental and says it is not a forecast; it looks at the surrounding 50 to 100 km of each coastal pixel, which is why neighboring beaches share a level. Data runs one to two days behind, and Seaweed Radar does not measure anything itself. See [how the levels work](https://seaweedradar.com/how-it-works/) for the rest.

## How do you check each island on Seaweed Radar?

Open [St. Thomas](https://seaweedradar.com/st-thomas/) or [St. Croix](https://seaweedradar.com/st-croix/) to see the current level for each beach with its data date, then use the by-month pages to compare your travel dates against the same month last year. Check the level for your week a few days before you fly, and again the morning of a beach day, since the data runs one to two days behind and a level can change from one run of data to the next. A Medium or High level is a reason to keep a second beach in mind, not a reason to cancel.

## Bottom line

For a winter trip, the record favors St. Thomas, especially in December. For April to August, plan for High levels on either island and choose by what else you want from the trip. For the wider picture, see [the US Virgin Islands overview](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/us-virgin-islands-sargassum-st-thomas-st-john-st-croix/).

## Questions

**Which Virgin Island has less seaweed, St. Thomas or St. Croix?**

In the daily record from July 2025 to November 16, 2026, St. Thomas had more Low days from November to February: Magens Bay was Low on 101 of those 120 days. St. Croix's beaches were Low on 66 to 88. In summer both islands ran High on most days.

**Is St. Croix worse than St. Thomas in winter?**

On the record so far, St. Croix had fewer Low days from November to February, especially in December, when Cane Bay was Low on 9 days and Rainbow Beach on 5. January was its quietest month, with 27 to 29 Low days.

**Does the north or south side of the island have less seaweed?**

Mostly the same level. On St. Thomas the open and sheltered beaches had the same highest level on 479 of 501 days, and on St. Croix on 493 of 501 days.

**Do the risk levels mean seaweed will be on the beach?**

No. A level describes seaweed offshore that could arrive. It is not a view of the sand and not a forecast, and the satellite product behind it is experimental.

## Sources

- [Seaweed Radar: St. Thomas seaweed by month](https://seaweedradar.com/st-thomas/by-month/)
- [Seaweed Radar: St. Croix seaweed by month](https://seaweedradar.com/st-croix/by-month/)
- [Seaweed Radar: St. Thomas open and sheltered beaches](https://seaweedradar.com/st-thomas/which-side/)
- [Seaweed Radar: St. Croix open and sheltered beaches](https://seaweedradar.com/st-croix/which-side/)
- [NOAA CoastWatch Caribbean and Gulf of America node: Daily Sargassum Inundation Risk (SIR v1.5)](https://cwcgom.aoml.noaa.gov/SIR/)

Tags: [st-thomas](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/st-thomas/), [st-croix](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/st-croix/), [us-virgin-islands](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/us-virgin-islands/), [compare-destinations](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/compare-destinations/), [by-month](https://seaweedradar.com/blog/tag/by-month/)

See the newest risk level for [399 beaches](https://seaweedradar.com/), or read [how the levels work](https://seaweedradar.com/how-it-works/).

## Morning report

The seaweed risk for your beach, by email at 7 AM local time, in English or Spanish. Each report gives the newest risk level for the coast around the beach: not a view of the sand, not a forecast.

- Every morning
- Once a week
- One weekend

[Choose a plan](https://seaweedradar.com/report/)

Trip Brief PDF with every plan. Payment on Gumroad.
