Satellite data from · the site updates once a day

Blog · Seaweed basics · · 4 min read

Brown Tide or Sargassum? Why Texas and Florida Water Turns Brown

Brown tide is a bloom of microscopic algae that turns the water itself brown. Sargassum is a floating seaweed you can pick up. Texas and Florida have both had brown tides, and the daily risk level covers only sargassum.

Brown water on a Texas or Florida shore isn't always seaweed, and the daily risk level covers only one of the possible causes. The name "brown tide" adds to the confusion. It is a different thing from sargassum.

What is brown tide?

Brown tide is a bloom of tiny single-celled algae that turns the water itself brown. Seaweed Radar's glossary names Texas's Laguna Madre and Florida's Indian River Lagoon as places where it has happened. The species behind both is Aureoumbra lagunensis, a microscopic alga whose golden cells are only 2.5 to 5 micrometres across, far too small to see one at a time.

It does well in warm, salty water. The densest blooms are recorded above a salinity of 40 PSU and at 25 to 30 °C, according to the species' reference entry. You won't see mats or strands. You see water that has changed colour, often cloudy rather than clean.

What is sargassum?

Sargassum is a brown seaweed that floats at the sea surface and never attaches to the seabed. It drifts in patches that range from a few centimetres to hundreds of metres across. That is the seaweed behind the beach reports from Florida and the Caribbean, and there is a fuller explanation of why sargassum is a seaweed.

You can pick it up. Once it piles on the sand and rots, it gives off hydrogen sulfide, a gas that smells of rotten eggs. That smell is a sargassum problem, not a brown tide one.

What happened in Texas and Florida?

Texas: Laguna Madre and Baffin Bay

Before 2012, brown tides of this species had been documented only in Texas estuaries, in Laguna Madre and Baffin Bay. The Laguna Madre bloom ran from 1990 to 1997, with drought and very salty water (45 to 75 PSU) helping it along. It was broken up by heavy rainfall by October 1997. Cloudier water cut the light reaching the seagrass beds, and those beds shrank. For a sense of the Texas coast on the sargassum side, see Galveston and South Padre seaweed by month.

Florida: the Indian River Lagoon

Florida's first documented brown tide was reported in July 2012 in the Indian River and Mosquito Lagoons on the east-central coast. Genetic work confirmed the same species as in Texas. Officials recorded a significant loss of seagrass, low oxygen, fish kills and deaths of farmed hard clams. A second bloom started in spring 2013. The Florida blooms each lasted no more than a few months. Juvenile clams and oysters filtered the brown water at lower than usual rates during the 2012 bloom, and the bloom's decline was tied to near-low-oxygen conditions and an unusually high number of fish kills. Researchers began tracking its return in May 2013.

How can you tell them apart at the shore?

Look at what is in the water, not just its colour.

Brown tide Sargassum
What it is Microscopic single-celled alga Floating brown seaweed
What you see Water that is brown or cloudy throughout Mats, strands and piles you can pick up
Smell Not a rotten-egg smell on its own Rotten eggs once it decays on the sand
Where it has been in Texas and Florida Laguna Madre, Baffin Bay, Indian River Lagoon Open sea, then beaches on the open coast
Health note Florida's wildlife agency says the organism is nontoxic, with no known human health concerns Decaying sargassum gives off hydrogen sulfide; ask a doctor about any symptoms

Brown tide can still hurt the water around it. Florida's wildlife agency notes that it can cut water clarity to under a foot in some cases and that fish kills can follow when oxygen runs low. It advises against touching, collecting or eating dead or dying fish.

Is brown tide the same as red tide?

No. Red tide in Florida and the Gulf is mostly a different alga, Karenia brevis. It has its own checks, covered in Sargassum vs red tide.

How do you check the coast on Seaweed Radar?

Open the page for your destination, such as Florida, and read the risk level and its data date. The level is a satellite-based risk for a run of coast, it is experimental, and it is not a forecast. It covers sargassum offshore that could arrive, and the data runs one to two days behind. How the risk level works explains the four levels.

It will not show brown tide, red tide or muddy water. If the water looks brown with no seaweed in it, the level is not the tool to settle why. A few things help narrow it down: whether there are mats or strands you can lift out of the water, whether the colour reaches into the shallows evenly, whether it followed heavy rain or wind, and whether the same stretch has looked this way for days. Local health and wildlife agencies publish notices when a bloom is confirmed, and those are the pages to read for a bloom, not a seaweed map.

A bloom of this kind tends to hang around lagoons and bays more than open surf beaches. That fits where it has been recorded: Laguna Madre and Baffin Bay in Texas, and the Indian River and Mosquito Lagoons in Florida are all sheltered, shallow and salty. Sargassum, by contrast, arrives from the open sea, so it is the open-coast beaches that catch it first.

Bottom line

Brown tide is a bloom of microscopic algae that colours the water. Sargassum is a floating seaweed that reaches beaches in mats. Texas and Florida have both had brown tides, and Seaweed Radar's risk level describes sargassum only.

Questions

Is brown water at the beach always sargassum?
No. Sargassum shows up as floating or stranded brown seaweed you can see and pick up. Water that is brown all the way through, with no mats in it, can be a bloom of microscopic algae such as brown tide, or it can be stirred-up sediment.
Is brown tide harmful to people?
Florida's wildlife agency says the brown tide organism is nontoxic and that there are no known human health concerns, but shellfish and fish kills can occur. The Florida Department of Health advises against touching, collecting or eating dead or dying fish. Ask a doctor about any health worry.
Does the daily seaweed risk level show brown tide?
No. The level describes sargassum offshore that could arrive on a run of coast. It does not measure brown tide, red tide or muddy water, and it is experimental and not a forecast.
Where has brown tide happened?
In Texas, in Laguna Madre and Baffin Bay. In Florida, in the Indian River Lagoon, where the first documented bloom was reported in July 2012.

Sources

Tags: brown-tide, sargassum, texas, florida, algal-bloom

See the newest risk level for 399 beaches, or read how the levels work.