Satellite data from · the site updates once a day

Blog · Seaweed basics · · 5 min read

Is Sargassum Safe to Eat or Garden With? What Arsenic Tests Show

No. A Florida county health department says not to cook with sargassum because it may hold arsenic and cadmium. For gardens, one small test found far more arsenic in vegetables, and no health page covers it.

The answer for eating is firm, and the answer for gardens is that nobody has settled it. Both come down to the same fact: sargassum soaks up arsenic from seawater, and a mat on the sand is not food and not tested fertilizer.

Is sargassum safe to eat?

No, and the health page that addresses it says so plainly. The Florida Department of Health in St. Johns County answers the question "Can I use Sargassum in cooking?" with a no: it says you should not use sargassum in cooking because it may contain large amounts of heavy metals like arsenic and cadmium.

It helps to separate this from the seaweed sold as food. Edible seaweeds are a different product, grown or harvested and then sold. A drifting mat that has washed up on a beach is neither, and the same US agency that writes about its arsenic says more study is needed on using sargassum as a raw material for food and cosmetics, and on what to do with it in the end. Nothing in that wording points to a tested route from beach to plate.

What do arsenic tests show about beached sargassum?

The EPA says sargassum accumulates and leaches pollutants, including heavy metals like arsenic, which could harm human health and the environment. It gives one measured figure: sargassum that washed onto beaches in Mexico in 2018 held 29.0 to 65.7 mg/kg of arsenic. That is above what the French food safety agency recommends for human consumption of seaweeds.

The same page says the arsenic can move through the food web. It reports that edible bivalves found where sargassum collects in Martinique had arsenic above French consumption recommendations. Those findings concern shellfish at one set of beaches. Read them as a warning about arsenic in this seaweed, not as a number for every coast.

What did the garden test find?

A June 2022 news report from the Virgin Islands describes a small planter-box test by WWF-Mexico and STINAPA Bonaire. One box held a 50-50 mix of potting soil and dried sargassum, and the other held potting soil only. Vegetables from the sargassum box had four times as much arsenic in spinach, 21 times as much in zucchini and 37 times as much in bok choy. Cadmium was also higher, though the report gives no figures for it. The vegetables grew to a similar size and number in both boxes, so a healthy-looking harvest told you nothing about what was in it.

Keep the limits in mind. It was two boxes, and what we have is a news report of the test, not the study itself. The report says the implications are not quite clear. Even so, the scientists it quotes urged farmers to stop using sargassum as fertilizer for food crops, or in animal feed, until more studies are done.

Can you garden or compost with sargassum?

The sources don't say, and this site won't guess. Neither the EPA page nor the Florida health page covers compost, mulch or fertilizer. The only test above points one way: more arsenic in the vegetables. Some commercial products claim to have removed the metals by processing sargassum, and the news report notes that claim, but it does not check it.

If you are weighing it for a food garden, the cautious reading is to hold off until there is research on arsenic in crops, and to ask your local extension or health office before you spread anything. This is not medical advice; for a health question, ask a doctor.

What is known and what is not?

Question What the sources say
Eating it Do not cook with it: arsenic and cadmium (Florida health page)
Arsenic in beached mats 29.0 to 65.7 mg/kg in Mexico in 2018 (EPA)
Vegetables from a sargassum mix 4x, 21x and 37x the arsenic in a small test (news report)
Compost or mulch Not covered by the health pages
Processed liquid fertilizer Makers claim the metals are removed; the report does not verify it

The gaps are as important as the numbers. No source here tells you a safe amount, a safe use or a safe way to prepare it, so none is offered.

How should you handle sargassum on the beach?

Wear gloves, and keep your distance from a rotting pile. The Florida page says to use gloves if you must handle seaweed, and the EPA says workers who collect it should consider gloves, boots and respiratory protection. The EPA also says the hydrogen sulfide and ammonia from decay typically start once a mat has been beached for about 48 hours.

For the swimming and walking side of the question, see what health pages say about walking through seaweed and what officials say about swimming in sargassum. To see why the piles are there, read who cleans the seaweed, and for what the plant is, the two species behind the mats.

How do you check the seaweed risk on your coast?

Open the beach or destination page on Seaweed Radar and read the daily risk level and its data date. The level describes seaweed offshore that could arrive, for a run of coast 20 to 190 km long, and the data runs one to two days behind. It is experimental and not a forecast. Start with how the levels work, look up a term in the glossary, or open a destination such as Florida or Riviera Maya.

Bottom line

Do not eat sargassum from the beach, and treat it as unproven for food gardens. Wear gloves if you have to touch it, and rely on local health guidance for anything beyond that.

Questions

Is sargassum safe to eat?
A Florida county health department says you should not use sargassum in cooking because it may contain large amounts of heavy metals like arsenic and cadmium. The EPA reports arsenic in beached sargassum from Mexico in 2018 above French recommendations for eating seaweed.
Can I use beach sargassum as garden fertilizer?
The EPA and the Florida page do not address fertilizer or compost. A small planter-box test reported much more arsenic in vegetables grown in a sargassum mix, and its scientists urged caution for food crops until more studies are done.
Does the planter-box test prove sargassum is unsafe for gardens?
No. It was a small test known from a news report, and that report says the implications are not quite clear. It is a reason for caution, not a final answer.
Is it safe to touch sargassum on the beach?
The Florida page advises gloves if you must handle it, because small organisms living in the seaweed may irritate skin. It says sargassum itself does not sting or cause rashes.

Sources

Tags: sargassum, arsenic, health, heavy-metals, fertilizer

See the newest risk level for 399 beaches, or read how the levels work.