Blog · Seaweed basics · · 4 min read
How Seaweed Changes Caribbean Fishing: Nets, Catches and Prices
Seaweed mats tangle nets and lines, flood engines, clog harbours and shift what fishers catch. Fewer fish can mean higher prices and different menus, and the effect varies by island and by year.
Most of what travellers hear about seaweed is about sand and smell. For fishers it is a working problem at sea, at the harbour and in the market, and it has been one since 2011.
The sources below are mostly about the eastern Caribbean, with Barbados and Tobago the best documented. Effects differ by island, by year and by fishery, so treat them as a pattern, not a rule for every coast.
What does seaweed do to nets, lines and engines?
It tangles gear and slows everything down. The US EPA says excess sargassum can entangle fishing gear such as nets and lines and reduce access to fishing grounds, which leads to lower catch rates and reduced income. It also notes that changed fish behaviour can mean fewer days at sea and lower profits.
Fishers put it more bluntly. A fisher from Delaford Bay, Tobago, told FAO that when he is at sea his lines get entangled with the weed, which badly affects his catch that day. A flying fish fisher in Buccoo, Tobago, said he had to change two engines because sargassum flooded them, and that it is costly.
The University of the West Indies' CERMES reports that fishers agree on the main points: sargassum can damage boat engines and gear, and the result is lost fishing time and higher operating costs. For more on the boating side, see what skippers report about mats.
How do seaweed mats block harbours and landing sites?
By piling up exactly where boats start and finish the day. FAO says large blooms have clogged fishing harbours and mooring sites across the eastern Caribbean, so fishers cannot get to their boats or their usual catches. The EPA's page shows the same problem in Martinique, where an inundation kept fishermen from getting boats out.
CERMES gives a sense of scale: eastern Caribbean islands can receive up to 100 metric tonnes of sargassum per kilometre of beach per day during influx events, and the weed can clog water up to 200 metres offshore. The mats mostly arrive from the east, which is why they travel west and why the eastern islands feel it first.
Which fish are lost and which are gained?
Both happen, which is the part most summaries skip. CERMES says some fishers reported better catches of species and sizes they do not normally take, such as yellow and almaco jacks and small dolphinfish, while others had significant declines.
Flyingfish
Flyingfish are the clearest loss. In Barbados they would normally make up about 60% of the annual landed catch, and CERMES reports that in sargassum years they have essentially disappeared from fish markets and restaurant menus. Its chart, built on data from Oxenford and colleagues (2019), shows Barbados flyingfish landings down by more than half (52%) after the first influx in 2011. FAO's own research puts the drop at 50 percent for Barbados.
Dolphinfish and mahi mahi
Dolphinfish went another way. Very young fish travel with the sargassum and arrive earlier in the year than the traditional season. Taking those small fish can look like a bonanza, but CERMES says it is likely behind the near disappearance of larger dolphinfish later in the season and a marked fall in total weight landed. The same chart shows Barbados dolphinfish landings down 37% since 2011, and FAO reports mahi mahi down 37 percent.
The two sources word their figures a little differently, so read the numbers as a rough size of the change in Barbados, not a measure for the whole region.
Why do fish prices and menus change?
Because supply shifts. FAO's fisheries expert in Barbados puts it simply: if there is less fish, the prices go up and there is less work, which hits consumers and market vendors who have less to sell. The EPA lists higher prices or changes in the availability of certain species among the market effects on fishing operations.
None of these sources gives a price, so this article does not either. What they do support is the direction: fewer of the usual fish, and a different mix of what is on offer. FAO adds that fishers have had to change techniques and target species in years with a lot of sargassum.
Decomposing mats can also harm fish directly. The EPA says decomposing blooms release hydrogen sulfide and ammonia, reduce oxygen and can kill commercially important species, and CERMES links the same process to fish-kills.
What might you notice as a visitor?
Possibly a different catch of the day. In a heavy year on an eastern island, a flyingfish dish may be harder to find, while something else is plentiful. That is a pattern in the reports, not a promise about any menu or any week.
For your own dates, the useful question is how much seaweed is offshore near the coast you are visiting. Seaweed Radar shows a daily satellite-based risk level for a run of coast, one to two days behind. It is experimental and not a forecast, and it does not tell you what a restaurant will serve. How much warning a seaweed risk level gives explains the limits, How it works covers the levels, and the Eastern Caribbean page is the place to start for the islands most affected.
Bottom line
For fishers, seaweed is a work problem before it is a beach problem: tangled gear, flooded engines, blocked harbours and a changed catch. Barbados flyingfish and dolphinfish show how uneven the effect can be, and fewer fish tends to mean higher prices and fewer jobs along the supply chain. Check the daily record for your coast, and expect the local menu to vary.
Questions
- Does seaweed make fish more expensive in the Caribbean?
- It can. FAO's fisheries expert says that when there is less fish, prices go up, and the US EPA lists higher prices and changed availability of species among the market effects. None of the sources used here gives a price figure, so the size of any change is not stated.
- Can you still eat local fish during a heavy seaweed year?
- Usually something local is on the menu, but which fish changes. The University of the West Indies' CERMES reports that in Barbados flyingfish have essentially disappeared from fish markets and restaurant menus in sargassum years, while other species, such as small dolphinfish and jacks, have shown up more.
- Does seaweed kill fish?
- Decomposing sargassum releases hydrogen sulfide and ammonia and lowers oxygen in the water, which can kill commercially important species, according to the US EPA. CERMES also links decomposing sargassum to fish-kills.
Sources
- US EPA: Sargassum Inundation Events (SIEs): Impacts on the Economy
- FAO: Seeking solutions to sargassum algae in the Caribbean
- University of the West Indies Cave Hill, CERMES: Sargassum research
Tags: fishing, flyingfish, barbados, eastern-caribbean, fish-prices
See the newest risk level for 399 beaches, or read how the levels work.