Satellite data from · the site updates once a day

Blog · On the trip · · 4 min read

Why Offshore Seaweed Is Not Simply Scooped Up Before It Lands

Federal fisheries rules prohibit harvesting sargassum in U.S. waters from 3 to 200 nautical miles out, south of the North Carolina and South Carolina boundary.

Satellites can track mats of seaweed long before they land, so scooping them up at sea sounds like the obvious fix. Three things get in the way: the rules, the habitat the mats provide, and the plain problem of where the collected seaweed goes. This page uses the same terms as the glossary.

Is it allowed to harvest sargassum at sea?

Not in most U.S. federal waters along the southern coast. NOAA Fisheries prohibits harvest of sargassum in all U.S. federal waters, from 3 to 200 nautical miles offshore, south of the North Carolina and South Carolina state boundary. The EPA describes the same limit as strictly prohibited under federal fisheries regulations, with extra rules on seasons and gear for harvest.

Inside 3 miles the picture changes. States and territories may set their own permit requirements and restrictions for collecting sargassum in nearshore waters, so there is no single answer for a given beach.

This covers U.S. waters only. Mexico, the Dominican Republic and other countries set their own rules, and this article does not cover them.

Why do floating mats count as habitat?

Because animals live in them. Floating sargassum gives food, shelter and breeding grounds to hundreds of marine species. Gray triggerfish, amberjack and mahi mahi are among the fish that feed on the small life in the rafts, and a Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council post puts the count at about 120 fish species and more than 120 invertebrate species.

Young animals use it too. Juvenile sea turtles and sea birds rely on the rafts for food and shelter, and in the North Atlantic and the Gulf, sargassum is one of the essential features of designated critical habitat for loggerhead sea turtles.

In the South Atlantic, the Gulf and the Caribbean, parts of it are also designated Essential Fish Habitat. That label alone does not ban harvest, but federal activities that could affect it need a consultation. The EPA adds that these protected habitat designations legally limit managing sargassum until it is fully beached.

Federal agencies that authorize, fund or carry out a harvest that could affect listed species must consult under the Endangered Species Act, and private operators are encouraged to seek an incidental take permit if they cannot avoid interactions. Even where a harvest is not flatly banned, it comes with obligations that a casual offshore scoop would not meet.

That is the other half of the question. The same mats that arrive as a problem on a beach are, while they float, a nursery. If you want the reason they head toward Caribbean and Florida coasts in the first place, read why the mats travel west.

Why is disposal the hard part?

Collecting seaweed is one job. Getting rid of it is another job entirely. The EPA says it is generally not practical to store sargassum on floating platforms or to dispose of it in the ocean, so even places that collect it near shore end up bringing it onto land. Proposals to sink it at sea may need a permit under the Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act.

NOAA describes cleanup options as limited and costly. A mat picked up in open water still has to be brought ashore and handled there, so reaching it sooner does not remove the disposal problem.

Pulling it from the water early does have one upside: collecting it directly from the water prevents dead or dying seaweed from sinking. But it still has to be hauled somewhere.

Floating barriers are the other idea, and they are the nearest thing to stopping mats before landfall. Booms and similar barriers can deflect mats away from a coastline, and they have been used with mixed results. The Army Corps of Engineers should be consulted before barriers go into nearshore waters, because they can affect navigation.

Where does collection actually happen?

Mostly at the shoreline. The EPA notes that many jurisdictions, including some in the U.S., remove sargassum soon after it washes onto beaches and before it decomposes. Heavy machinery can carry away large quantities of sand, so best practice is to plan around erosion, native vegetation and trapped marine life such as baby turtles.

How that plays out depends on the place. Miami Beach runs daily county crews under a state permit, while some Jamaican beaches wait for a rake. Neither one is a case of scooping at sea. In both places the work starts after the seaweed has reached land, which is the point at which the habitat protections described by the EPA stop limiting management.

How do you plan around seaweed that will not be removed offshore?

Check the risk level for your coast on Seaweed Radar. It shows satellite-based risk for a run of coast 20 to 190 km long, not for one beach, and it describes seaweed offshore that could arrive, not what is on the sand. The data runs one to two days behind, and the level is experimental and not a forecast. How it works explains each of the four levels, and how many days of warning a forecast gives sets realistic expectations for planning.

For a Florida trip, start from the Florida page and open the beach you are considering. Each beach page states which way the beach faces, which is one of the things that changes the odds.

Bottom line

Offshore removal is not a dependable shield. In U.S. federal waters south of the Carolinas harvest is prohibited, the mats are habitat for fish and young turtles, and collected seaweed still needs a place to go. Plan around the daily record for your coast, not around cleanup you can't see.

Questions

Is it illegal to collect sargassum at sea?
NOAA Fisheries prohibits harvest of Sargassum in all U.S. federal waters, from 3 to 200 nautical miles offshore, south of the North Carolina and South Carolina state boundary. States and territories may have their own permit rules for nearshore waters, so what applies inside 3 miles varies.
Do any places remove sargassum before it reaches the beach?
According to the EPA, some jurisdictions in the tropical Atlantic collect it from nearshore waters before it lands. They still dispose of it onshore, because storing it on floating platforms or dumping it at sea is generally not practical.
Do floating barriers keep seaweed off a beach?
The EPA describes booms and barriers that deflect mats offshore as having been used with mixed results, and says the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers should be consulted before barriers are placed in nearshore waters.

Sources

Tags: sargassum, sargassum-removal, essential-fish-habitat, federal-waters, on-the-trip

See the newest risk level for 399 beaches, or read how the levels work.