Satellite data from · the site updates once a day

Blog · Reading the risk · · 4 min read

What 'Experimental' Means on NOAA's Sargassum Risk Map

Experimental means the method is still being tested and improved, so the map can change, pause or arrive late. It does not mean the map is wrong, and it is a separate statement from the fact that it is not a forecast.

The word sits at the top of the page that publishes the daily Sargassum Inundation Risk, and it is easy to skim past. NOAA labels the map an experimental product. That label shapes how much weight a colour can carry.

Here is what the producers say, what the map is built to do, what can change under it, and how to use it on a trip.

What do the map's producers say about it?

They say three things, in this order: it is an experimental product, it is updated daily, and it is not a forecast. That wording opens the page and is repeated in its disclaimer.

The disclaimer goes further. It says the data are at various levels of quality and maturity, that no warranty is made, and that fitness for any third-party use cannot be determined. In plain terms, use it, but don't lean your whole plan on it.

The Seaweed Radar glossary puts the label this way: a product still being tested and improved, which can change, pause or arrive late. It is offered as a guide to what is offshore.

What is the map built to do?

It rates the risk that floating sargassum near a stretch of coast washes ashore there. It is built from satellite-derived floating algae data supplied by the University of South Florida.

For each coastal pixel, the method looks at the surrounding 50 to 100 km and compares it with a multiday baseline. The difference sorts the coast into four levels: low, warning, medium and high. Areas with too little data are marked black. The map is a joint effort of NOAA's Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory, its CoastWatch and OceanWatch teams, and USF.

On Seaweed Radar each level carries a letter (L, W, M, H) as well as a colour. The map rates a risk, so it does not record that seaweed landed. For that distinction, see what a sargassum inundation event is.

Is experimental the same as not a forecast?

No, and the page makes both statements separately.

Experimental describes the method: it is still maturing. Not a forecast describes the claim: the map shows current satellite conditions and the potential for seaweed to arrive, not a prediction of a landing on a date. The 2023 FAQ adds the reason. Whether seaweed actually reaches a shore depends on local current, tide, wind and wave conditions, none of which the satellite picture settles.

A map can be experimental and careful, or mature and still not a forecast. This one is experimental and not a forecast, which gives you two reasons to hold a single colour loosely.

What can change, pause or arrive late?

Quite a lot. Some of it already has.

  • Levels and cadence. The 2023 FAQ described three levels and weekly updates. The current dashboard shows four levels and says daily. If you read an older explainer, check it against the current page.
  • The satellite source. The 2023 FAQ said the sensor behind the data was nearing the end of its mission and that other sensors were being added. A method that depends on one sensor has to adapt when it changes.
  • The date. The map runs one to two days behind the calendar, so the colour you see describes a slightly earlier picture. How often the daily risk level changes explains why a level often holds for days even though a new map arrives each day.

An experimental product can also pause or arrive late. When that happens, Seaweed Radar keeps the last map and shows how old it is. A day with no map is counted as missing, never as low.

What does the label not tell you?

Experimental says how mature the method is. It does not say how your beach looks this morning.

The level is about seaweed offshore that could arrive. It says nothing about whether a hotel raked the sand at six, or whether the wind moved yesterday's mat past the point. It also covers a long run of coast, usually 20 to 190 km, with one level for the whole run, which is why two beaches can share one level.

The last stretch before the sand is the hardest to see from space, because the land muddles satellite images there. Seaweed very close in can be missed.

How do you use an experimental map for a trip?

Hold it loosely. Don't ignore it.

  1. Read the data date before the colour.
  2. Look at the level for the run of coast that includes your beach.
  3. Compare several days, not one. A level that has held for a week says more than a single reading.
  4. Read a high level for what it is: what a high level does and does not say about your beach.

How to check this on Seaweed Radar

Seaweed Radar repeats the daily risk level for the coast around twenty beaches and shows the date of the map it quotes. Open your destination, for example Cancún or Punta Cana, pick the beach, and read the date, the last 14 days and the by-month record in that order. The How Seaweed Radar works page explains the routine. Seaweed Radar does not measure anything itself, and NOAA, NASA and USF do not endorse it.

Bottom line

Experimental means the method is still being tested, so the map can change, pause or arrive late and comes with no warranty. It does not mean the map is wrong. Read the date, read the level for your run of coast, and treat it as a risk, not a prediction.

Questions

Does experimental mean the sargassum risk map is wrong?
No. It means the method is still being tested and improved, so it can change and comes with no warranty. The map is still published as a guide to where floating sargassum is near a coast. Read the date, read the level for your run of coast, and treat it as one input.
Is the sargassum risk map a forecast?
No. Its producers say so in plain words. The map estimates the potential for floating sargassum to wash ashore, using satellite data. Whether seaweed lands depends on local current, tide, wind and waves.
Why do older descriptions of the map differ from today's?
Because the product has changed. A 2023 FAQ described three levels and weekly updates. The current dashboard shows four levels and says it is updated daily. That kind of change is what the experimental label allows for.
How should I use an experimental map when planning a trip?
Check the data date first, then the level for the stretch of coast, then compare several days rather than one. Treat it as a hint about the open water offshore, not a promise about one beach on one morning.

Sources

Tags: experimental-product, risk-level, not-a-forecast, satellite-data, data-date

See the newest risk level for 399 beaches, or read how the levels work.