Satellite data from · the site updates once a day

Blog · Seaweed basics · · 4 min read

Sargassum or Kelp? Why the Beach Seaweed Is Not a Kelp Forest

The brown seaweed on Caribbean and Florida beaches is sargassum, not kelp. Both are brown algae, but kelp forms dense forests in cold, shallow water, while sargassum drifts free at the surface.

Both are brown algae, both get called seaweed, and both can form big floating masses, so the two names get swapped a lot. Their lives couldn't be more different, though. That difference explains why a Caribbean beach gets sargassum and never a kelp forest.

What is kelp, and where does a kelp forest grow?

Start with the one most visitors never see in the tropics.

Kelp is a large brown alga that lives in cool, relatively shallow water close to shore and grows in dense groupings, much like a forest on land.

According to NOAA, these canopies generally occur in cold, nutrient-rich water. Kelp needs light for photosynthesis, so forests form in shallow open water and are rarely found deeper than 49 to 131 feet. In good conditions kelp can grow up to 18 inches a day.

The forests NOAA describes run along much of the west coast of North America. They shelter seals, sea lions, sea otters and many birds, and they hold more variety of plants and animals than almost any other ocean community. Storms and events like El Niño can tear kelp loose, and the forest starts growing back each spring.

So what is the brown seaweed on the beach?

On Caribbean, Gulf and Florida beaches the brown seaweed is sargassum, a floating brown algae also known as Gulf weed. It stays afloat on gas-filled bladders called pneumatocysts.

The two species that matter in the Gulf and Atlantic, Sargassum natans and Sargassum fluitans, are free-floating. The Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council says neither spends any of its life attached to the seafloor, and that they reproduce only by fragmentation, when a young piece breaks off and grows into a full plant. Most sargassum lives a year or less.

If you have ever wondered about the other plants that turn up on the sand, our guide to seagrass or sargassum covers what else washes up.

Sargassum vs kelp: what are the real differences?

The short version: kelp is a forest, and sargassum is a drifter. They share a color and a family resemblance. They differ in where they grow, how they grow and where people run into them. Here is the comparison.

Kelp Sargassum
Type Large brown algae Large brown algae
Where it grows Cool, nutrient-rich, shallow water near shore Open ocean, at the surface
How it grows Dense canopies, like a forest Free-floating mats and rafts
Where you meet it West coast of North America Sargasso Sea, tropical Atlantic, Caribbean and Gulf
What it does for wildlife Shelter and food for seals, otters, birds, fish Food, shelter and breeding grounds for hundreds of species offshore

One caveat, to keep the picture honest: the Gulf council notes that sargassum in general can attach to rocks or reefs, like kelp but smaller. The seaweed that arrives on regional beaches is the free-floating kind.

Why do Caribbean beaches get sargassum and not kelp?

Kelp needs cold, nutrient-rich shallows, and warm tropical shorelines do not offer that. Sargassum has no such requirement, because it drifts, and the ocean has been moving it toward the tropics.

Historically most sargassum sat in the Sargasso Sea, in the western North Atlantic. In 2011 its range expanded: a new population, driven by shifting wind patterns, now thrives in the open ocean in what is called the Great Atlantic Sargassum Belt. NOAA says currents carry large amounts of it west into the Caribbean Sea, the Gulf and the tropical South Atlantic. Our explainer on the arrivals since 2011 tells that story year by year, and another shows how the winds and currents carry the mats west.

Does the difference matter on the sand?

Yes. The friendly image of a kelp forest doesn't carry over to a pile of sargassum on the beach.

Offshore, sargassum is useful, and NOAA designates areas of it as Essential Fish Habitat in the South Atlantic, the Gulf and the Caribbean. Its rafts shelter fish such as gray triggerfish, amberjack and mahi mahi, and young sea turtles and sea birds use it for food and cover. Once large masses reach shore, that changes. As sargassum decomposes it gives off hydrogen sulfide, a gas that smells like rotten eggs and can irritate the respiratory system. NOAA also notes that sargassum can contain high levels of arsenic and other heavy metals, which is covered in more detail in our piece on arsenic and other heavy metals in sargassum. For any health question, ask a doctor.

How can you check the coast before you go?

Check the daily risk level for the stretch of coast your beach sits on. Seaweed Radar shows a satellite-based risk level for a run of coast, not for one beach, and it runs one to two days behind. It describes seaweed offshore that could arrive, not what is on the sand, and the underlying product is experimental and not a forecast.

Start with how the daily risk level works, look up your destination, such as Cancún, and see the glossary if a term is unfamiliar.

Bottom line

Kelp and sargassum are both brown algae, but kelp grows as a forest in cold, shallow water and sargassum floats free in the open ocean. The seaweed on a Caribbean or Florida beach is sargassum. Check the risk level for your coast before you travel, ideally again a day or two before you leave since conditions shift, and treat it as a guide to the odds, not a promise.

Questions

Is sargassum a type of kelp?
No. Both are large brown algae, but kelp forms dense forests in cool, nutrient-rich, shallow water, while the sargassum that reaches Caribbean and Gulf beaches floats freely at the surface and never attaches to the seafloor.
Can kelp wash up on a Caribbean beach?
The brown seaweed that piles up on Caribbean and Florida beaches is sargassum. The kelp forests NOAA describes grow along the west coast of North America in cold water, which is not the setting of a Cancún or Punta Cana beach.
Why does sargassum float?
The Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council describes it as floating thanks to gas-filled bladders called pneumatocysts.
Is floating sargassum bad for the ocean?
Offshore it is habitat: NOAA says it gives food, protection and breeding grounds to hundreds of marine species. The trouble starts when large masses reach shore and begin to decay.

Sources

Tags: sargassum, kelp, seaweed-basics, great-atlantic-sargassum-belt

See the newest risk level for 399 beaches, or read how the levels work.