Blog · Reading the risk · · 4 min read
Cloud Gaps: What Happens to the Seaweed Map on Cloudy Days
Satellites cannot see through cloud, so a cloudy day leaves holes in the picture of the sea. The risk map is put together from several days of images to fill them, and a stretch with too little data is marked as such, not as low.
What matters is how old the picture is, not how cloudy it was. A level you read in a stormy week can rest on images from several different days. The date printed on the page tells you which.
Why do clouds leave holes in the seaweed map?
Because the satellites can't look through them. The glossary puts it this way: the satellites that find sargassum see sunlight reflected off the sea, so they cannot see through cloud. Where cloud sits over the water, there's nothing to measure.
NOAA's own illustration of how sensors are combined shows the problem in colour. In its caption for images from August 2, 2022, light turquoise is sargassum, medium blue is cloud and dark blue is water. Cloud gets a colour of its own in the picture, and it hides whatever lies underneath.
Cloud isn't the only thing that limits the view. Nearshore, the last stretch before the sand, is the hardest part to read, because the land itself muddles satellite images. Seaweed close in is the hardest to see from space, with or without cloud.
How does the map fill the holes?
By putting several days of images together. The how it works page says the map is made from satellite images of floating sargassum collected over the previous week. A patch of sea hidden on Monday may be in view on Wednesday, and the later pass fills in the earlier gap.
The map's method follows the same idea. For each coastal pixel, the algorithm examines the data in the surrounding 50 to 100 km and compares them with a multiday baseline, according to the page that publishes the daily product. The difference sets the level: low, warning, medium or high.
More than one satellite helps too. NOAA's satellite team says that combining data from different sensors enhances detection by filling gaps and improving spatial resolution. Its example merges three sensors: VIIRS on NOAA-20, MODIS on Terra and OLCI on Sentinel-3. That page does not say the gaps it means are cloud gaps, so read it as one more way holes get filled, not as a cloud fix.
NASA adds that data from its PACE satellite's ocean color instrument now feeds the University of South Florida's near-real-time daily and weekly composite maps, alongside MODIS and VIIRS. A composite is a map built from many passes, which is the same trick used here: more looks, fewer holes.
How often the daily level changes is a separate question from how it is built, and worth a read if a level seems to sit still for days.
What does a gap look like on the map?
Black. On the daily map, black means insufficient data. A stretch of coast with too little to go on isn't coloured as low. It is left without a level.
Seaweed Radar follows the same caution. A day the satellite team did not publish is counted as missing in a beach's history, never as low. If the daily map is skipped, the page keeps the last map it has and says how old it is.
That rule matters because a missing day and a quiet day can look alike at a glance. Treating a cloudy blank as a calm one would flatter every stormy week.
What stays the same on a cloudy week?
The nature of the map. It is experimental, it is not a forecast, and it rates the risk of sargassum arriving rather than recording whether it did. If you want the longer version, here is what experimental means on the risk map.
A cloudy week does not change what a level covers either. It is still a run of coast 20 to 190 km long, not one beach, which is why two beaches can share one level.
How should you read a level after cloudy days?
Start with the data date, not the colour. The map runs one to two days behind the calendar, so every Seaweed Radar page shows the date of the map it is quoting and how old it is. A date a day or two back is normal. A much older one means NOAA skipped days, and the page says so.
Then look at the days around it. The beach page shows the last fourteen days, so you can see whether a level is one reading among several or a sudden jump. A single odd reading after a run of cloud deserves less weight than a level that has held for a week.
Do not read a low level after a cloudy stretch as proof of clear sand. The map describes seaweed offshore that could arrive, and the satellites see the sea better than they see the shoreline. What a high level does and does not say about your beach covers the same limits from the other side.
Where do you check the level for your beach?
On Seaweed Radar, on the page for the beach or coast you are going to. For Cancún, start at the Cancún destination page and pick the beach, for example Playa Delfines. The page shows the level, the date of the data and how old it is, and the last fourteen days.
Bottom line
Clouds hide the sea from the satellites, so the map is built from several days of images, and a stretch with too little data is marked as such, not as low. Read the data date first, then the days around it, and treat the level as a risk offshore, not a promise about the sand.
Questions
- Can a cloudy day make the seaweed risk level look lower than it is?
- A hole in the imagery is not read as clear water. The map marks a stretch with too little data as insufficient data, and Seaweed Radar counts a day that was not published as missing, never as low. A level is still built from several days of images, so check the data date on the page.
- Why is the map built from a week of images?
- Any single day can be partly hidden by cloud, so the satellite images are collected over the previous week and put together. That gives the map more of the sea to look at than one day would.
- Does a cloudy forecast for my trip mean the map is wrong?
- No. Cloud over the beach and cloud over the satellite's view of the sea are different things at different times. The map is experimental and not a forecast either way, so it says nothing about the weather on your day.
Sources
- NOAA CoastWatch Caribbean and Gulf Regional Node: Daily Sargassum Inundation Risk (SIR v1.5)
- NOAA NESDIS: Orbiting Insights, Transforming Sargassum Seaweed Detection and Monitoring From Space
- NASA Earth Observatory: Sizing Up the Sargassum Belt
- Seaweed Radar: Glossary
- Seaweed Radar: How Seaweed Radar works
Tags: satellite-data, clouds, risk-level, data-date
See the newest risk level for 399 beaches, or read how the levels work.